Just a few hours ago,
Roadrunner Records have released the third and final video following the bands auditions for a new drummer. As a fan of Dream Theater (Not
too hardcore, but I care) this week has been very exciting. The loss of Mike Portnoy left an empty feeling, so I was very glad to actually see the potential drummers and their talents.
Now normally, I wouldn't feel the need to blog about something like this, at least not to the extent that I feel necessary, but Roadrunner seems to have some restrictions on their videos, so not everyone who wants to can actually see them. I'll provide links for those who want them along with a guide, so that those of you who can't access Roadrunner Records' Youtube channel can still get a feel of what went on. Ultimately though, if you're a fan, the videos were interesting enough to view them via proxy. Just a suggestion.
None of the videos are embeddable and all 3 are a bit over 20 minutes in length, making the set come out to just over an hour.
The first few minutes of episode one talk mainly about Portnoy, the shock in the loss and the rest of the bands opinion on his leaving. They mention how he wanted a hiatus and then come back and have an amazing reunion. They weren't thrilled for the idea, and so Mike left the band, and now they're on their quest to find a worthy drummer. They have selected what in their opinion are 7 of the greatest drummers in the world.
This episode, having contributed so much to the story of how they got to this point, focuses mainly on Mike Mangini. He tells the camera how deeply he wants to be involved in the band, how it's not just a gig to him and how he feels that ones soul has to be into it.
Let's look at Mangini's impressive history! He's been a drummer for:
Extreme
Annihilator
Steve Vai.
He's also a professor at Berklee College of Music
All 7 drummers have to go through 3 different tests. A jam session, 3 classic Dream Theater songs and then they have to cope with a complicated musical piece composed by Jordan Rudess.
The 3 songs they all had to go through were
A Nightmare To Remember, from their most recent album,
Black Clouds and Silver Linings, it is the "heavy" song. There was also
The Dance of Eternity, which is extremely progressive and difficult, along with
The Spirit Carries On, a slower song. The last two are both from Metropolis pt II, Scenes From A Memory.
(Which is an amazing album I don't care what anybody says. It's musical genius.) If you're not familiar with the songs, I wrote a bit more about them here.
Mike Mangini was one of the few drummers who manged to ace all three tests. Giving his own flair and enthusiasm while staying true to the Dream Theater theme. They admitted that he raised the bar very high for the future 6 drummers.
Before the end, as a teaser, they mentioned someone else outdoing themselves and possibly taking Mangini's top spot.
Episode 2 features 4 drummers.
Derek Roddy
Hate Eternal
Malevolent Creation
Serpent's Rise
Derek was noted for his blast speed, being the very Metal drummer that he is, he definitely captured attention. While they did love him, he didn't have the right fit. He was a fun contender, but he wasn't an obvious choice.
Thomas Lang
John Wetton of King Crimson
Falco
Mick Jones of The Clask
Glenn Hughes of Deep Purple
Marco showed some issues at one point during the 3 classic songs. He made some very noted interpretations, but he didn't quite get it right. He also had some trouble adapting to Jordan's oddly timed new music. While the band did love him, he wouldn't be fit for the job.
Virgil Donati
Planet X
Southern Sons
And has performed with Steve Vai
He was one of the drummers they just had to test out. Especially considering he had performed in a Dream Theater cover band. He had nice chemistry with the band and seemed to enjoy himself very much. I personally found him to be a nice fit, but he did improvise on the three songs just a bit, trying to do some really neat tricks. Ultimately, the band didn't feel perfect about it.
and
Marco Minneman who has performed with
Paul Gilbert
Adrian Belew of King Crimson
Kreator
Necrophagist
He was probably the happiest of the drummers auditioned and to come. A smile on his face, his energy was probably that of a 5 year old on Christmas morning. Maybe just a tad more mature. Kinda looks like Tom Green, too...
He fit right in with the jams, laughing his way through, as well as perfectly hitting the classics. He took some time to get Jordan's composition down, but he was able to accompany the riffs well. He scored perfectly in the bands eyes. Up there with Mike Mangini.
Warning! I will spoil it by the end of this section.
Two drummers were auditioned on this one. They were
Aquiles Priester
Hangar
Freakeys
Vinnie Moore Band
Aquiles was the only drummer who had real problems getting to the auditions. He had canceled part of his tour in Brazil to prepare for the auditions and had some visa issues. Luckily he made it. Sadly, he wasn't quite prepared. He did mess up a little on the classics and wasn't sure how to handle Jordan's composition. The end result was a fun time, but quite obviously not the best choice for a drummer.
Peter Wildoer
Darkane
Pestilence
James LeBrie Solo Project
Yet another drummer who had instant chemistry. Initially, he too aced all 3 tests, leaving 3 final drummers from which to pick from.
The issue with Peter Wildoer was that while he was perfect, the band didn't feel like they meshed with him as well as they did with Thomas Lang or Mike Mangini. Leaving him discarded, and having two drummers to pick from. With such a difficult decision, it's a wonder they were able to pick on such a short time.
The episode shows them wondering and arriving to a decision, they decide to call Peter up and let him know on the news and how he didn't make it. Peter took it really well. They then call Mike Mangini and allow him "into the family". He becomes emotional, a very happy Mangini shall now be the second Mike on the drums with an amazing band.
I am personally happy with their decision and look forward to the different vibes. I'm really looking forward to what he may bring. So congratulations Mike! Make the fans proud.
Regular posts will resume tomorrow. I'm a total fan. I'm allowed to make a silly post every once in a while.